
Valiant Effort Ends in Heartbreak as Hartford Athletic Bow out on Penalties at Pittsburgh
Published on November 1, 2025 under United Soccer League Championship (USL)
Hartford Athletic News Release
Hartford Athletic fell to Pittsburgh Riverhounds SC 4-2 on penalty kicks after battling the Pennsylvania side to a 0-0 draw over 120+ minutes of play. The Green & Blue defended valiantly through two overtime periods but were unlucky when it came to a penalty kick shootout.
The Boys in Green started off strong, testing goalkeeper Eric Dick twice in the first two minutes. In fact, Samuel Careaga found the back of the net less than 90 seconds into the match, but the attempt was ruled offside.
A few minutes later, Michee Ngalina was brought down by Luke Biasi as he streaked toward goal. The referee awarded Biasi a yellow card and Hartford was granted a free kick. Sebastian Anderson played the ball short to Careaga who passed it on to Emmanuel Samadia. Hartford's "cross boss" put the ball into the box, but no one was able to get on the end of it.
Around the half hour mark, Antony Siaha made a crucial save to keep Athletic within striking distance. Pittsburgh was awarded a free kick and Robbie Mertz took the set piece, serving a beautiful outswinger into the box. Beto Ydrach got his head on the end of it and the ball was headed for the bottom right post, but Siaha stretched out his 6'5" frame to block the shot and keep the home team scoreless.
The first half was a battle for the midfield, with neither team creating many dangerous chances, and the two sides went into the locker room with an xG of 0.29 for Pittsburgh and 0.17 for Hartford.
The second stanza continued much in the same fashion, with Hartford defending as a team to keep the Riverhounds off the scoreboard.
In added time, TJ Presthus made a clutch diving block to deny Pittsburgh and ensure the game went into overtime.
Even as the home team pounded the Hartford goal, the Boys in Green held strong, rejecting every opportunity the Riverhounds tried to muster. After 30 minutes of battle, the game went to penalty kicks, where the Green & Blue fell 4-2 in a devastating end to the side's playoff run.
This marks the end of the Hartford Athletic season for 2025. Season tickets for 2026 are on sale now.
FAST STATS
HARTFORD PITTSBURGH
Shots 6 11
Shots On Target 3 1
Corners 8 1
Fouls 21 11
Offsides 4 2
Possession 37.1% 62.9%
Passing Accuracy 57.4% 77.3%
Saves 3 3
SCORING SUMMARY
HARTFORD PITTSBURGH
PENALTY KICKS
HARTFORD PITTSBURGH
Hadji Barry - X Bertin Jacquessonn - G
Joe Farrell - G Robbie Mertz - G
Jack Panayotou - G Augustine Williams - G
Samuel Careaga - X Sean Suber - G
DISCIPLINARY SUMMARY
HARTFORD PITTSBURGH
43 ¬Â² - Beverly Makangila (Yellow) 8 ¬Â² - Luke Biasi (Yellow)
58 ¬Â² - Antony Siaha (Yellow) 58 ¬Â² - Robbie Mertz (Yellow)
90 ¬Â² - Marlon Hairston (Yellow)
90 ¬Â² - Bench (Yellow)
90+8 ¬Â² - Junior Moreira (Yellow)
109 ¬Â² - Joshua Belluz (Yellow)
LINEUPS
HARTFORD PITTSBURGH
77 (GK) Antony Siaha 1 (GK) Eric Dick
22 (DF) TJ Presthus 23 (DF) Guillaume Vacter (Illial Osumanu, 88 ¬Â²)
15 (DF) Joe Farrell (C) 5 (DF) Sean Suber
30 (DF) Adrián Diz Pe (Owen Presthus, 80 ¬Â²) 16 (DF) Roberto Ydrach
2 (DF) Sebastian Anderson 8 (MF) Brunallergene Junior Etou
94 (MF) Marlon Hairston (Jack Panayotou, 117 ¬Â²) 15 (MF) Bradley Sample (Bertin Jacquesson, 91 ¬Â²)
10 (MF) Samuel Careaga 2 (MF) Daniel Griffin (C)
6 (MF) Beverly Makangila (Junior Moreira, 46 ¬Â²) 13 (MF) Luke Biasi (Perrin Barnes, 62 ¬Â²)
19 (MF) Emmanuel Samadia 14 (FW) Robbie Mertz
11 (FW) Michee Ngalina (Joshua Belluz, 90+3 ¬Â²) 12 (FW) Charles Ahl (Jackson Wälti, 78 ¬Â²)
71 (FW) Kyle Edwards (Jonathan Jiménez, 60 ¬Â²) (Hadji Barry, 116 ¬Â²) 9 (FW) Augustine Williams
United Soccer League Championship Stories from November 1, 2025
- FC Tulsa Stuns Switchbacks with Extra-Time Winner, Makes Playoff History - FC Tulsa
- San Antonio FC Falls, 0-2, to New Mexico in Western Conference Quarterfinals - San Antonio FC
- El Paso Locomotive FC Fall in First Round of Playoffs to Phoenix Rising FC - El Paso Locomotive FC
- New Mexico United Advances to Western Conference Semifinals with 2-0 Victory Over San Antonio FC - New Mexico United
- New Mexico United Advances to Western Conference Semifinals with 2-0 Victory Over San Antonio FC - New Mexico United
- Hounds Advance in PK Shootout Over Hartford - Pittsburgh Riverhounds SC
- Switchbacks FC Fall on the Road to FC Tulsa - Colorado Springs Switchbacks FC
- Detroit City FC Defeats Top-Seeded Louisville City FC in the First Round of the USL Championship Playoffs - Detroit City FC
- Match Recap - USL Championship Playoffs Round 1 - Loudoun United FC
- Riverhounds Advance on PK Shootout - Pittsburgh Riverhounds SC
- LouCity's Historic Campaign Comes to Abrupt First-Round Ending at Hands of Detroit - Louisville City FC
- Valiant Effort Ends in Heartbreak as Hartford Athletic Bow out on Penalties at Pittsburgh - Hartford Athletic
- Anderson's early goal leads NCFC to Eastern Conference Quarterfinal win - North Carolina FC
- Republic FC and Jamaican Striker Khori Bennett Launch Donation Campaign to Support Families Impacted by Hurricane Melissa - Sacramento Republic FC
- Sidelined to Success: Kyle Edwards' Championship Journey Fueled by Expert Care from Trinity Health of New England - Hartford Athletic
The opinions expressed in this release are those of the organization issuing it, and do not necessarily reflect the thoughts or opinions of OurSports Central or its staff.
Other Recent Hartford Athletic Stories
- Valiant Effort Ends in Heartbreak as Hartford Athletic Bow out on Penalties at Pittsburgh
- Sidelined to Success: Kyle Edwards' Championship Journey Fueled by Expert Care from Trinity Health of New England
- The Road to Glory: Hartford Athletic Travels to Pittsburgh in First Round of the Playoffs
- Boys in Green Set to Open Playoffs with a Battle in the 'Burgh
- Hartford Athletic Falls 1-0 to Louisville City in Regular Season Finale


