| | | |
| October 25, 2019 | W | Mentor Ice Breakers 3 at Watertown Wolves 1 | Final |
| October 26, 2019 | L | Mentor Ice Breakers 1 at Watertown Wolves 3 | Final |
| November 1, 2019 | W | Mentor Ice Breakers 7 at Battle Creek Rumble Bees 2 | Final |
| November 2, 2019 | W | Mentor Ice Breakers 5 at Battle Creek Rumble Bees 0 | Final |
| November 8, 2019 | W | Mentor Ice Breakers 5 at Battle Creek Rumble Bees 3 | Final |
| November 9, 2019 | W | Battle Creek Rumble Bees 3 at Mentor Ice Breakers 10 | Final |
| November 15, 2019 | W | Mentor Ice Breakers 5 at Delaware Thunder 2 | Final |
| November 16, 2019 | L | Delaware Thunder 3 at Mentor Ice Breakers 2 | Final |
| November 17, 2019 | W | Danville Dashers 4 at Mentor Ice Breakers 7 | Final |
| November 22, 2019 | L | Port Huron Prowlers 4 at Mentor Ice Breakers 2 | Final |
| November 23, 2019 | W | Port Huron Prowlers 3 at Mentor Ice Breakers 6 | Final |
| November 27, 2019 | L | Mentor Ice Breakers 1 at Columbus River Dragons 3 | Final |
| November 29, 2019 | L | Mentor Ice Breakers 5 at Columbus River Dragons 7 | Final |
| November 30, 2019 | W | Mentor Ice Breakers 6 at Columbus River Dragons 3 | Final |
| December 6, 2019 | L | Mentor Ice Breakers 2 at Danville Dashers 3 | Final |
| December 7, 2019 | L | Mentor Ice Breakers 3 at Danville Dashers 5 | Final |
| December 13, 2019 | W | Mentor Ice Breakers 6 at Battle Creek Rumble Bees 1 | Final |
| December 14, 2019 | W | Battle Creek Rumble Bees 2 at Mentor Ice Breakers 6 | Final |
| December 20, 2019 | L | Twin City Thunderbirds 5 at Mentor Ice Breakers 1 | Final |
| December 21, 2019 | L | Twin City Thunderbirds 2 at Mentor Ice Breakers 1 | Final |
| December 26, 2019 | W | Danbury Hat Tricks 5 at Mentor Ice Breakers 6 | Final |
| December 27, 2019 | L | Port Huron Prowlers 2 at Mentor Ice Breakers 0 | Final |
| December 28, 2019 | L | Port Huron Prowlers 4 at Mentor Ice Breakers 2 | Final |
| December 31, 2019 | L | Mentor Ice Breakers 0 at Danville Dashers 3 | Final |
| January 3, 2020 | W | Mentor Ice Breakers 4 at Danville Dashers 2 | Final |
| January 4, 2020 | L | Danville Dashers 2 at Mentor Ice Breakers 1 | Final |
| January 10, 2020 | L | Mentor Ice Breakers 2 at Twin City Thunderbirds 3 | Final |
| January 11, 2020 | L | Mentor Ice Breakers 0 at Twin City Thunderbirds 3 | Final |
| January 17, 2020 | L | Danville Dashers 4 at Mentor Ice Breakers 2 | Final |
| January 18, 2020 | L | Danville Dashers 4 at Mentor Ice Breakers 2 | Final |
| January 20, 2020 | W | Battle Creek Rumble Bees 2 at Mentor Ice Breakers 4 | Final |
| January 24, 2020 | L | Mentor Ice Breakers 1 at Twin City Thunderbirds 4 | Final |
| January 25, 2020 | L | Mentor Ice Breakers 2 at Twin City Thunderbirds 7 | Final |
| January 26, 2020 | L | Twin City Thunderbirds 4 at Mentor Ice Breakers 3 | Final |
| January 31, 2020 | L | Mentor Ice Breakers 2 at Port Huron Prowlers 4 | Final |
| February 1, 2020 | L | Mentor Ice Breakers 2 at Port Huron Prowlers 9 | Final |
| February 7, 2020 | L | Mentor Ice Breakers 1 at Columbus River Dragons 10 | Final |
| February 8, 2020 | L | Mentor Ice Breakers 3 at Columbus River Dragons 7 | Final |
| February 14, 2020 | L | Mentor Ice Breakers 2 at Port Huron Prowlers 7 | Final |
| February 15, 2020 | L | Mentor Ice Breakers 3 at Port Huron Prowlers 4 | Final |
| February 21, 2020 | L | Elmira Enforcers 5 at Mentor Ice Breakers 2 | Final |
| February 22, 2020 | L | Elmira Enforcers 5 at Mentor Ice Breakers 0 | Final |
| February 28, 2020 | L | Port Huron Prowlers 7 at Mentor Ice Breakers 4 | Final |
| February 29, 2020 | L | Port Huron Prowlers 7 at Mentor Ice Breakers 3 | Final |
| March 1, 2020 | L | Mentor Ice Breakers 2 at Danville Dashers 7 | Final |
| March 5, 2020 | L | Elmira Enforcers 4 at Mentor Ice Breakers 1 | Final |
| March 6, 2020 | L | Elmira Enforcers 10 at Mentor Ice Breakers 3 | Final |
| March 8, 2020 | W | Delaware Thunder 5 at Mentor Ice Breakers 6 | Final |
| March 13, 2020 | | Mentor Ice Breakers at Delaware Thunder | Cancelled |
| March 14, 2020 | | Mentor Ice Breakers at Delaware Thunder | Cancelled |
| March 15, 2020 | | Mentor Ice Breakers at Delaware Thunder | Cancelled |
| March 20, 2020 | | Mentor Ice Breakers at Danbury Hat Tricks | Cancelled |
| March 21, 2020 | | Mentor Ice Breakers at Danbury Hat Tricks | Cancelled |
| March 27, 2020 | | Watertown Wolves at Mentor Ice Breakers | Cancelled |
| March 28, 2020 | | Watertown Wolves at Mentor Ice Breakers | Cancelled |
| March 29, 2020 | | Watertown Wolves at Mentor Ice Breakers | Cancelled |
| April 3, 2020 | | Mentor Ice Breakers at Elmira Enforcers | Cancelled |
| April 4, 2020 | | Mentor Ice Breakers at Elmira Enforcers | Cancelled |
Mentor Ice Breakers Schedule
