| | | |
| October 14, 2023 | L | Elmira River Sharks 3 at Binghamton Black Bears 7 | Final |
| October 20, 2023 | | Elmira River Sharks at Watertown Wolves | Ppd. |
| October 21, 2023 | W | Watertown Wolves 0 at Elmira River Sharks 4 | Final |
| October 26, 2023 | W | Binghamton Black Bears 3 at Elmira River Sharks 4 | Final |
| November 3, 2023 | W | Motor City Rockers 2 at Elmira River Sharks 3 | Final |
| November 4, 2023 | L | Motor City Rockers 4 at Elmira River Sharks 1 | Final |
| November 11, 2023 | L | Danbury Hat Tricks 6 at Elmira River Sharks 5 | Final |
| November 17, 2023 | L | Elmira River Sharks 3 at Binghamton Black Bears 8 | Final |
| November 18, 2023 | L | Danbury Hat Tricks 8 at Elmira River Sharks 1 | Final |
| November 24, 2023 | L | Motor City Rockers 3 at Elmira River Sharks 2 | Final |
| November 25, 2023 | L | Motor City Rockers 7 at Elmira River Sharks 2 | Final |
| December 1, 2023 | L | Elmira River Sharks 4 at Binghamton Black Bears 6 | Final |
| December 2, 2023 | L | Watertown Wolves 6 at Elmira River Sharks 5 | Final |
| December 8, 2023 | W | Watertown Wolves 3 at Elmira River Sharks 8 | Final |
| December 15, 2023 | W | Elmira River Sharks 8 at Watertown Wolves 5 | Final |
| December 16, 2023 | W | Danbury Hat Tricks 2 at Elmira River Sharks 4 | Final |
| December 22, 2023 | L | Elmira River Sharks 4 at Motor City Rockers 8 | Final |
| December 23, 2023 | L | Elmira River Sharks 1 at Motor City Rockers 9 | Final |
| December 29, 2023 | L | Binghamton Black Bears 7 at Elmira River Sharks 3 | Final |
| December 30, 2023 | L | Elmira River Sharks 4 at Watertown Wolves 6 | Final |
| December 31, 2023 | W | Watertown Wolves 2 at Elmira River Sharks 6 | Final |
| January 5, 2024 | L | Danbury Hat Tricks 6 at Elmira River Sharks 1 | Final |
| January 12, 2024 | L | Elmira River Sharks 3 at Columbus River Dragons 4 | Final |
| January 13, 2024 | L | Elmira River Sharks 1 at Columbus River Dragons 4 | Final |
| January 19, 2024 | W | Watertown Wolves 2 at Elmira River Sharks 4 | Final |
| January 20, 2024 | W | Elmira River Sharks 4 at Watertown Wolves 2 | Final |
| January 25, 2024 | L | Port Huron Prowlers 3 at Elmira River Sharks 2 | Final |
| January 26, 2024 | L | Port Huron Prowlers 5 at Elmira River Sharks 1 | Final |
| January 27, 2024 | L | Elmira River Sharks 2 at Binghamton Black Bears 9 | Final |
| January 28, 2024 | L | Elmira River Sharks 0 at Watertown Wolves 4 | Final |
| February 2, 2024 | W | Elmira River Sharks 5 at Port Huron Prowlers 1 | Final |
| February 3, 2024 | L | Elmira River Sharks 4 at Port Huron Prowlers 5 | Final |
| February 9, 2024 | W | Danbury Hat Tricks 3 at Elmira River Sharks 7 | Final |
| February 10, 2024 | W | Elmira River Sharks 6 at Danbury Hat Tricks 3 | Final |
| February 11, 2024 | W | Binghamton Black Bears 3 at Elmira River Sharks 6 | Final |
| February 14, 2024 | L | Binghamton Black Bears 10 at Elmira River Sharks 2 | Final |
| February 16, 2024 | W | Blue Ridge Bobcats 2 at Elmira River Sharks 3 | Final |
| February 17, 2024 | W | Blue Ridge Bobcats 2 at Elmira River Sharks 4 | Final |
| February 23, 2024 | L | Elmira River Sharks 2 at Danbury Hat Tricks 3 | Final |
| February 24, 2024 | L | Elmira River Sharks 4 at Danbury Hat Tricks 10 | Final |
| February 25, 2024 | W | Elmira River Sharks 2 at Watertown Wolves 1 | Final |
| March 1, 2024 | W | Binghamton Black Bears 3 at Elmira River Sharks 6 | Final |
| March 2, 2024 | L | Watertown Wolves 5 at Elmira River Sharks 3 | Final |
| March 8, 2024 | L | Binghamton Black Bears 5 at Elmira River Sharks 3 | Final |
| March 10, 2024 | W | Elmira River Sharks 4 at Danbury Hat Tricks 2 | Final |
| March 15, 2024 | L | Elmira River Sharks 1 at Danbury Hat Tricks 8 | Final |
| March 16, 2024 | L | Danbury Hat Tricks 3 at Elmira River Sharks 2 | Final |
| March 17, 2024 | L | Elmira River Sharks 1 at Binghamton Black Bears 8 | Final |
| March 22, 2024 | W | Elmira River Sharks 3 at Port Huron Prowlers 2 | Final |
| March 23, 2024 | L | Elmira River Sharks 2 at Port Huron Prowlers 3 | Final |
| March 30, 2024 | W | Watertown Wolves 2 at Elmira River Sharks 6 | Final |
| April 3, 2024 | L | Binghamton Black Bears 7 at Elmira River Sharks 3 | Final |
| April 5, 2024 | L | Elmira River Sharks 3 at Watertown Wolves 7 | Final |
| April 6, 2024 | L | Elmira River Sharks 3 at Watertown Wolves 4 | Final |
| April 7, 2024 | L | Elmira River Sharks 1 at Danbury Hat Tricks 8 | Final |
| April 13, 2024 | L | Elmira River Sharks 3 at Binghamton Black Bears 4 | Final |
Elmira River Sharks Schedule
