| | | |
| February 3, 2021 | | Elmira Enforcers at Watertown Wolves (Elmira forfeits) | Cancelled |
| February 4, 2021 | | Elmira Enforcers at Watertown Wolves | Cancelled |
| February 5, 2021 | | Watertown Wolves at Elmira Enforcers | Cancelled |
| February 6, 2021 | | Watertown Wolves at Elmira Enforcers | Cancelled |
| February 11, 2021 | | Elmira Enforcers at Watertown Wolves | Cancelled |
| February 12, 2021 | | Elmira Enforcers at Watertown Wolves | Cancelled |
| February 13, 2021 | | Watertown Wolves at Elmira Enforcers | Cancelled |
| February 14, 2021 | | Watertown Wolves at Elmira Enforcers | Cancelled |
| February 19, 2021 | W | Port Huron Prowlers 0 at Elmira Enforcers 10 | Final |
| February 20, 2021 | W | Port Huron Prowlers 1 at Elmira Enforcers 6 | Final |
| February 23, 2021 | W | Columbus River Dragons 3 at Elmira Enforcers 4 | Final |
| February 24, 2021 | L | Columbus River Dragons 2 at Elmira Enforcers 1 | Final (SO) |
| March 3, 2021 | W | Twin City Thunderbirds 3 at Elmira Enforcers 4 | Final |
| March 4, 2021 | L | Twin City Thunderbirds 4 at Elmira Enforcers 3 | Final (OT) |
| March 12, 2021 | W | Elmira Enforcers 3 at Port Huron Prowlers 1 | Final |
| March 13, 2021 | L | Elmira Enforcers 3 at Port Huron Prowlers 5 | Final |
| March 14, 2021 | L | Elmira Enforcers 1 at Port Huron Prowlers 2 | Final |
| March 17, 2021 | W | Twin City Thunderbirds 2 at Elmira Enforcers 4 | Final |
| March 19, 2021 | L | Elmira Enforcers 1 at Columbus River Dragons 5 | Final |
| March 20, 2021 | W | Elmira Enforcers 4 at Columbus River Dragons 2 | Final |
| March 21, 2021 | L | Elmira Enforcers 4 at Columbus River Dragons 5 | Final (OT) |
| March 26, 2021 | W | Elmira Enforcers 4 at Port Huron Prowlers 3 | Final |
| March 27, 2021 | W | Elmira Enforcers 4 at Port Huron Prowlers 3 | Final |
| April 2, 2021 | L | Twin City Thunderbirds 3 at Elmira Enforcers 2 | Final |
| April 3, 2021 | W | Twin City Thunderbirds 2 at Elmira Enforcers 4 | Final |
| April 4, 2021 | W | Twin City Thunderbirds 3 at Elmira Enforcers 4 | Final |
| April 7, 2021 | W | Port Huron Prowlers 1 at Elmira Enforcers 7 | Final |
| April 8, 2021 | W | Port Huron Prowlers 6 at Elmira Enforcers 8 | Final |
| April 9, 2021 | L | Elmira Enforcers 3 at Port Huron Prowlers 6 | Final |
| April 10, 2021 | L | Elmira Enforcers 0 at Port Huron Prowlers 3 | Final |
| April 16, 2021 | L | Twin City Thunderbirds 7 at Elmira Enforcers 6 | Final |
| April 17, 2021 | L | Twin City Thunderbirds 4 at Elmira Enforcers 2 | Final |
| April 18, 2021 | W | Twin City Thunderbirds 2 at Elmira Enforcers 4 | Final |
| April 23, 2021 | L | Columbus River Dragons 4 at Elmira Enforcers 2 (Champ. Gm. 1) | Final |
| April 24, 2021 | L | Columbus River Dragons 4 at Elmira Enforcers 3 (Champ. Gm. 2) | Final (2OT) |
| April 30, 2021 | L | Elmira Enforcers 1 at Columbus River Dragons 8 (Champ. Gm. 3) | Final |
Elmira Enforcers Schedule
