| | | |
| June 14, 2019 | W | Auburn Doubledays 0 at Batavia Muckdogs 2 | Final |
| June 15, 2019 | | Auburn Doubledays at Batavia Muckdogs | Susp. |
| June 16, 2019 | L | Batavia Muckdogs 7 at Mahoning Valley Scrappers 9 | Final |
| June 17, 2019 | L | Batavia Muckdogs 1 at Mahoning Valley Scrappers 3 | Final |
| June 18, 2019 | W | Auburn Doubledays 5 at Batavia Muckdogs 7 | Final |
| June 19, 2019 | L | Auburn Doubledays 5 at Batavia Muckdogs 0 | Final (7) |
| June 20, 2019 | | Batavia Muckdogs at Auburn Doubledays | Ppd. |
| June 21, 2019 | W | Batavia Muckdogs 3 at Williamsport Crosscutters 1 | Final |
| June 22, 2019 | W | Batavia Muckdogs 3 at Williamsport Crosscutters 1 | Final |
| June 23, 2019 | W | Batavia Muckdogs 6 at Williamsport Crosscutters 1 | Final |
| June 25, 2019 | W | West Virginia Black Bears 3 at Batavia Muckdogs 7 | Final |
| June 26, 2019 | W | West Virginia Black Bears 2 at Batavia Muckdogs 4 | Final |
| June 27, 2019 | L | West Virginia Black Bears 6 at Batavia Muckdogs 5 | Final (10) |
| June 28, 2019 | W | Batavia Muckdogs 9 at Mahoning Valley Scrappers 6 | Final |
| June 29, 2019 | L | Batavia Muckdogs 5 at Mahoning Valley Scrappers 6 | Final |
| June 30, 2019 | L | Batavia Muckdogs 2 at Mahoning Valley Scrappers 4 | Final |
| July 1, 2019 | W | State College Spikes 4 at Batavia Muckdogs 5 | Final (10) |
| July 2, 2019 | W | State College Spikes 0 at Batavia Muckdogs 1 | Final |
| July 3, 2019 | L | State College Spikes 6 at Batavia Muckdogs 4 | Final |
| July 4, 2019 | W | Batavia Muckdogs 3 at Auburn Doubledays 2 | Final |
| July 5, 2019 | W | Batavia Muckdogs 4 at Auburn Doubledays 1 | Final |
| July 6, 2019 | L | Batavia Muckdogs 3 at Auburn Doubledays 9 (Game 1) | Final |
| July 6, 2019 | | Batavia Muckdogs at Auburn Doubledays (Game 2) | Ppd. |
| July 7, 2019 | W | Batavia Muckdogs 3 at State College Spikes 2 | Final |
| July 8, 2019 | W | Batavia Muckdogs 14 at State College Spikes 2 | Final |
| July 9, 2019 | L | Batavia Muckdogs 5 at State College Spikes 7 | Final |
| July 10, 2019 | W | Lowell Spinners 6 at Batavia Muckdogs 8 | Final |
| July 11, 2019 | W | Lowell Spinners 2 at Batavia Muckdogs 5 | Final |
| July 12, 2019 | L | Lowell Spinners 5 at Batavia Muckdogs 2 | Final |
| July 13, 2019 | L | Batavia Muckdogs 0 at Vermont Lake Monsters 2 | Final |
| July 14, 2019 | W | Batavia Muckdogs 3 at Vermont Lake Monsters 1 | Final |
| July 15, 2019 | L | Batavia Muckdogs 1 at Vermont Lake Monsters 3 | Final |
| July 17, 2019 | W | Auburn Doubledays 0 at Batavia Muckdogs 11 | Final |
| July 18, 2019 | L | Auburn Doubledays 5 at Batavia Muckdogs 4 | Final |
| July 19, 2019 | W | Batavia Muckdogs 4 at Auburn Doubledays 3 (Game 1) | Final (7) |
| July 19, 2019 | W | Batavia Muckdogs 4 at Auburn Doubledays 1 (Game 2) | Final (7) |
| July 20, 2019 | W | Mahoning Valley Scrappers 2 at Batavia Muckdogs 7 | Final |
| July 21, 2019 | L | Mahoning Valley Scrappers 5 at Batavia Muckdogs 4 | Final |
| July 22, 2019 | W | Mahoning Valley Scrappers 1 at Batavia Muckdogs 4 | Final |
| July 23, 2019 | W | Batavia Muckdogs 8 at West Virginia Black Bears 3 | Final |
| July 24, 2019 | L | Batavia Muckdogs 2 at West Virginia Black Bears 8 | Final |
| July 25, 2019 | L | Batavia Muckdogs 3 at West Virginia Black Bears 4 | Final |
| July 26, 2019 | L | Williamsport Crosscutters 5 at Batavia Muckdogs 3 | Final |
| July 27, 2019 | L | Williamsport Crosscutters 7 at Batavia Muckdogs 0 | Final |
| July 28, 2019 | W | Williamsport Crosscutters 4 at Batavia Muckdogs 5 | Final |
| July 30, 2019 | W | Batavia Muckdogs 1 at Tri-City ValleyCats 0 | Final (6) |
| July 31, 2019 | W | Batavia Muckdogs 6 at Tri-City ValleyCats 5 | Final |
| August 1, 2019 | W | Batavia Muckdogs 4 at Tri-City ValleyCats 1 | Final |
| August 2, 2019 | W | Norwich Sea Unicorns 5 at Batavia Muckdogs 6 | Final |
| August 3, 2019 | L | Norwich Sea Unicorns 5 at Batavia Muckdogs 3 | Final |
| August 4, 2019 | L | Norwich Sea Unicorns 9 at Batavia Muckdogs 2 | Final |
| August 5, 2019 | L | Batavia Muckdogs 3 at Williamsport Crosscutters 9 | Final |
| August 6, 2019 | | Batavia Muckdogs at Williamsport Crosscutters | Ppd. |
| August 7, 2019 | W | Batavia Muckdogs 6 at Williamsport Crosscutters 3 (Game 1) | Final (7) |
| August 7, 2019 | W | Batavia Muckdogs 6 at Williamsport Crosscutters 3 (Game 2) | Final (7) |
| August 8, 2019 | L | Batavia Muckdogs 1 at State College Spikes 4 | Final |
| August 9, 2019 | L | Batavia Muckdogs 3 at State College Spikes 5 | Final |
| August 10, 2019 | W | Batavia Muckdogs 3 at State College Spikes 2 | Final (10) |
| August 11, 2019 | W | Mahoning Valley Scrappers 0 at Batavia Muckdogs 5 | Final |
| August 12, 2019 | L | Mahoning Valley Scrappers 5 at Batavia Muckdogs 0 | Final |
| August 13, 2019 | | Mahoning Valley Scrappers at Batavia Muckdogs | Ppd. |
| August 14, 2019 | W | West Virginia Black Bears 5 at Batavia Muckdogs 11 | Final |
| August 15, 2019 | L | West Virginia Black Bears 10 at Batavia Muckdogs 4 | Final |
| August 16, 2019 | L | West Virginia Black Bears 9 at Batavia Muckdogs 3 | Final |
| August 17, 2019 | L | Batavia Muckdogs 2 at Mahoning Valley Scrappers 11 | Final |
| August 18, 2019 | L | Batavia Muckdogs 0 at Mahoning Valley Scrappers 1 (Game 1) | Final (7) |
| August 18, 2019 | L | Batavia Muckdogs 0 at Mahoning Valley Scrappers 8 (Game 2) | Final (6) |
| August 19, 2019 | W | Batavia Muckdogs 8 at Mahoning Valley Scrappers 6 | Final |
| August 22, 2019 | W | State College Spikes 5 at Batavia Muckdogs 9 | Final |
| August 23, 2019 | W | State College Spikes 5 at Batavia Muckdogs 7 | Final |
| August 24, 2019 | L | State College Spikes 1 at Batavia Muckdogs 0 | Final |
| August 25, 2019 | L | Williamsport Crosscutters 10 at Batavia Muckdogs 3 | Final |
| August 26, 2019 | W | Williamsport Crosscutters 0 at Batavia Muckdogs 10 | Final |
| August 27, 2019 | L | Williamsport Crosscutters 11 at Batavia Muckdogs 4 | Final |
| August 28, 2019 | W | Batavia Muckdogs 8 at West Virginia Black Bears 7 | Final (10) |
| August 29, 2019 | L | Batavia Muckdogs 4 at West Virginia Black Bears 5 | Final (10) |
| August 30, 2019 | W | Batavia Muckdogs 4 at West Virginia Black Bears 1 | Final |
| August 31, 2019 | L | Auburn Doubledays 12 at Batavia Muckdogs 5 | Final |
| September 1, 2019 | L | Auburn Doubledays 3 at Batavia Muckdogs 1 | Final |
| September 2, 2019 | W | Batavia Muckdogs 7 at Auburn Doubledays 0 | Final |
| September 4, 2019 | W | Lowell Spinners 1 at Batavia Muckdogs 4 (Playoff Gm. 1) | Final |
| September 5, 2019 | L | Batavia Muckdogs 1 at Lowell Spinners 2 (Playoff Gm. 2) | Final |
| September 6, 2019 | L | Batavia Muckdogs 3 at Lowell Spinners 4 (Playoff Gm. 3) | Final (10) |
Batavia Muckdogs Schedule
