| | | |
| September 8, 2023 | W | Johnstown Tomahawks 5 at Maryland Black Bears 1 | Final |
| September 9, 2023 | L | Johnstown Tomahawks 3 at Maryland Black Bears 6 | Final |
| September 13, 2023 | W | El Paso Rhinos 1 at Johnstown Tomahawks 4 (Blaine, MN) | Final |
| September 14, 2023 | L | Kenai River Brown Bears 4 at Johnstown Tomahawks 2 (Blaine, MN) | Final |
| September 15, 2023 | W | Johnstown Tomahawks 3 at Aberdeen Wings 2 (Blaine, MN) | Final |
| September 16, 2023 | L | Johnstown Tomahawks 2 at Amarillo Wranglers 5 (Blaine, MN) | Final |
| September 22, 2023 | W | Johnstown Tomahawks 6 at Philadelphia Rebels 3 | Final |
| September 23, 2023 | W | Johnstown Tomahawks 1 at Philadelphia Rebels 0 | Final |
| September 30, 2023 | L | New Hampshire Mountain Kings 5 at Johnstown Tomahawks 3 | Final |
| October 1, 2023 | W | New Hampshire Mountain Kings 1 at Johnstown Tomahawks 2 | Final |
| October 6, 2023 | L | Johnstown Tomahawks 2 at Rochester Jr. Americans 3 | Final |
| October 7, 2023 | L | Johnstown Tomahawks 4 at Rochester Jr. Americans 5 | Final (OT) |
| October 13, 2023 | L | New Jersey Titans 4 at Johnstown Tomahawks 2 | Final |
| October 14, 2023 | W | New Jersey Titans 4 at Johnstown Tomahawks 6 | Final |
| October 27, 2023 | W | Johnstown Tomahawks 5 at New Jersey Titans 3 | Final |
| October 28, 2023 | L | Johnstown Tomahawks 2 at New Jersey Titans 5 | Final |
| November 4, 2023 | W | Johnstown Tomahawks 6 at Northeast Generals 1 | Final |
| November 5, 2023 | W | Johnstown Tomahawks 4 at Northeast Generals 3 | Final |
| November 10, 2023 | W | Philadelphia Rebels 1 at Johnstown Tomahawks 4 | Final |
| November 11, 2023 | W | Philadelphia Rebels 1 at Johnstown Tomahawks 4 | Final |
| November 17, 2023 | L | Johnstown Tomahawks 4 at Maine Nordiques 7 | Final |
| November 18, 2023 | L | Johnstown Tomahawks 2 at Maine Nordiques 3 | Final (OT) |
| November 24, 2023 | L | Rochester Jr. Americans 3 at Johnstown Tomahawks 1 | Final |
| November 25, 2023 | W | Rochester Jr. Americans 4 at Johnstown Tomahawks 7 | Final |
| November 26, 2023 | L | Rochester Jr. Americans 3 at Johnstown Tomahawks 0 | Final |
| December 8, 2023 | W | Johnstown Tomahawks 3 at New Hampshire Mountain Kings 0 | Final |
| December 9, 2023 | W | Johnstown Tomahawks 6 at New Hampshire Mountain Kings 3 | Final |
| December 15, 2023 | L | Maryland Black Bears 5 at Johnstown Tomahawks 4 | Final |
| December 16, 2023 | L | Maryland Black Bears 3 at Johnstown Tomahawks 1 | Final |
| December 17, 2023 | L | Maryland Black Bears 4 at Johnstown Tomahawks 2 | Final |
| December 30, 2023 | W | Northeast Generals 1 at Johnstown Tomahawks 2 | Final |
| December 31, 2023 | W | Northeast Generals 2 at Johnstown Tomahawks 3 | Final |
| January 5, 2024 | W | New Jersey Titans 3 at Johnstown Tomahawks 4 | Final (OT) |
| January 6, 2024 | W | New Jersey Titans 1 at Johnstown Tomahawks 5 | Final |
| January 12, 2024 | W | Johnstown Tomahawks 5 at Danbury Jr. Hat Tricks 1 | Final |
| January 13, 2024 | L | Johnstown Tomahawks 1 at Danbury Jr. Hat Tricks 5 | Final |
| January 26, 2024 | W | Maine Nordiques 4 at Johnstown Tomahawks 5 | Final (SO) |
| January 27, 2024 | W | Maine Nordiques 0 at Johnstown Tomahawks 2 | Final |
| February 2, 2024 | W | Danbury Jr. Hat Tricks 1 at Johnstown Tomahawks 6 | Final |
| February 3, 2024 | W | Danbury Jr. Hat Tricks 1 at Johnstown Tomahawks 4 | Final |
| February 9, 2024 | W | Johnstown Tomahawks 7 at Philadelphia Rebels 5 | Final |
| February 10, 2024 | L | Johnstown Tomahawks 2 at Philadelphia Rebels 4 | Final |
| February 16, 2024 | W | New Hampshire Mountain Kings 4 at Johnstown Tomahawks 6 | Final |
| February 17, 2024 | L | New Hampshire Mountain Kings 7 at Johnstown Tomahawks 5 | Final |
| February 23, 2024 | W | Johnstown Tomahawks 4 at Northeast Generals 2 | Final |
| February 24, 2024 | L | Johnstown Tomahawks 3 at Northeast Generals 4 | Final (SO) |
| March 1, 2024 | W | Johnstown Tomahawks 4 at New Hampshire Mountain Kings 2 | Final |
| March 2, 2024 | L | Johnstown Tomahawks 2 at New Hampshire Mountain Kings 3 | Final |
| March 6, 2024 | L | Rochester Jr. Americans 6 at Johnstown Tomahawks 0 | Final |
| March 8, 2024 | W | Northeast Generals 0 at Johnstown Tomahawks 2 | Final |
| March 9, 2024 | W | Northeast Generals 3 at Johnstown Tomahawks 5 | Final |
| March 15, 2024 | W | Johnstown Tomahawks 4 at Rochester Jr. Americans 3 | Final (SO) |
| March 16, 2024 | L | Johnstown Tomahawks 3 at Rochester Jr. Americans 5 | Final |
| March 20, 2024 | W | Maryland Black Bears 3 at Johnstown Tomahawks 4 | Final |
| March 22, 2024 | T | Philadelphia Rebels 1 at Johnstown Tomahawks 1 | Final (SO) |
| March 23, 2024 | W | Philadelphia Rebels 0 at Johnstown Tomahawks 6 | Final |
| March 29, 2024 | W | Johnstown Tomahawks 5 at New Jersey Titans 2 | Final |
| March 30, 2024 | L | Johnstown Tomahawks 2 at New Jersey Titans 6 | Final |
| April 5, 2024 | L | Johnstown Tomahawks 1 at Maryland Black Bears 4 | Final |
| April 6, 2024 | W | Johnstown Tomahawks 4 at Maryland Black Bears 1 | Final |
| April 12, 2024 | L | New Jersey Titans 3 at Johnstown Tomahawks 2 (Playoff Gm. 1) | Final (OT) |
| April 13, 2024 | L | New Jersey Titans 4 at Johnstown Tomahawks 1 (Playoff Gm. 2) | Final |
Johnstown Tomahawks Schedule
