| | | |
| December 29, 2022 | W | Syracuse Spark 12 at Jim Thorpe All-Americans 15 (Hagersville, ON) | Final |
| January 7, 2023 | W | Jim Thorpe All-Americans 15 at Charlotte Bootleggers 10 | Final |
| January 13, 2023 | L | Jim Thorpe All-Americans 11 at Trenton Terror 14 | Final |
| January 21, 2023 | W | Jim Thorpe All-Americans 14 at New England Chowderheads 9 | Final |
| January 28, 2023 | W | Jim Thorpe All-Americans 18 at Binghamton Bombers 8 | Final |
| February 4, 2023 | | Binghamton Bombers at Jim Thorpe All-Americans | Cancelled |
| February 11, 2023 | | Charlotte Bootleggers at Jim Thorpe All-Americans | Cancelled |
| February 18, 2023 | | New England Chowderheads at Jim Thorpe All-Americans | Cancelled |
| March 5, 2023 | | Jim Thorpe All-Americans at Hampton Hammerheads | Cancelled |
| March 10, 2023 | | Trenton Terror at Jim Thorpe All-Americans | Cancelled |
| March 18, 2023 | | Salem Mayhem at Jim Thorpe All-Americans | Cancelled |
| March 31, 2023 | | Jim Thorpe All-Americans at Salem Mayhem | Cancelled |
| April 9, 2023 | | Jim Thorpe All-Americans at Syracuse Spark | Cancelled |
| April 15, 2023 | | Hampton Hammerheads at Jim Thorpe All-Americans | Cancelled |
Jim Thorpe All-Americans Schedule
