PDA

View Full Version : Objective League Ratings


DazedAndAmused
04-08-2008, 05:39 PM
This is a repost from early January....I didn't change my grades to accommodate known facts at end of season, but I think it holds up to a degree. The ABA score goes down even further because of an assumed 50% play rate.


Dleague - Overall Score: 99

Objective:
-game play rate - excluding weather related cancellations(weight: 25%) 25
-average attendance (weight: 20%) average of 2K or more to achieve all pts 20
-average salary (weight: 10%) average of 2k/mo per play to achieve all pts 10
-teams that stay from previous year (weight: 10%) 9
-# of D1 players per roster (weight: 5%) 5

Last 3 more subjective:
-peripheral issues - eg, complaints of players not getting paid, no underperformers (weight: 10%) 10
-innovation - eg, technology use and deployment (weight: 5%) 5
-marketing - eg, national sponsors, high profile officers/board members/commissioners, tv presence (weight: 5%) 5

CBA - Overall Score: 89

Objective:
-game play rate - excluding weather related cancellations(weight: 25%) 24
-average attendance (weight: 20%) average of 2K or more to achieve all pts 20
-average salary (weight: 10%) average of 2k/mo per play to achieve all pts 10
-teams that stay from previous year (weight: 10%) 7
-# of D1 players per roster (weight: 5%) 5

Last 3 more subjective:
-peripheral issues - eg, complaints of players not getting paid, no underperformers (weight: 10%) 5
-innovation - eg, technology use and deployment (weight: 5%) 5
-marketing - eg, national sponsors, high profile officers/board members/commissioners, tv presence (weight: 5%) 3


PBL - Overall Score: 75 (yes, it's early but this is the prelim grade)

Objective:
-game play rate - excluding weather related cancellations(weight: 25%) 25
-average attendance (weight: 20%) average of 2K or more to achieve all pts 12
-average salary (weight: 10%) average of 2k/mo per play to achieve all pts 8
-teams that stay from previous year (weight: 10%) 10
-# of D1 players per roster (weight: 5%) 4

Last 3 more subjective:
-peripheral issues - eg, complaints of players not getting paid, no underperformers (weight: 10%) 8
-innovation - eg, technology use and deployment (weight: 5%) 3
-marketing - eg, national sponsors, high profile officers/board members/commissioners, tv presence (weight: 5%) 5

IBL - Overall Score: 55

Objective:
-game play rate - excluding weather related cancellations(weight: 25%) 22
-average attendance (weight: 20%) average of 2K or more to achieve all pts 5
-average salary (weight: 10%) average of 2k/mo per play to achieve all pts 4
-teams that stay from previous year (weight: 10%) 10
-# of D1 players per roster (weight: 5%) 3

Last 3 more subjective:
-peripheral issues - eg, complaints of players not getting paid, no underperformers (weight: 10%) 8
-innovation - eg, technology use and deployment (weight: 5%) 2
-marketing - eg, national sponsors, high profile officers/board members/commissioners, tv presence (weight: 5%) 1

ABA - Overall Score: 30

Objective:
-game play rate - excluding weather related cancellations(weight: 25%) 12
-average attendance (weight: 20%) average of 2K or more to achieve all pts 3
-average salary (weight: 10%) average of 2k/mo per play to achieve all pts 3
-teams that stay from previous year (weight: 10%) 2
-# of D1 players per roster (weight: 5%) 3

Last 3 more subjective:
-peripheral issues - eg, complaints of players not getting paid, no underperformers (weight: 10%) 0
-innovation - eg, technology use and deployment (weight: 5%) 4
-marketing - eg, national sponsors, high profile officers/board members/commissioners, tv presence (weight: 5%) 3

Paul S
04-08-2008, 06:39 PM
Good info and good rankings too.

The ABA has to lose some points for the sheer disorganization of the mechanics of the league though. Its like a rudderless ship just floating in whatever direction the tide seems to pull it.